Wiesner and Napoli’s "FISH GIRL"
Book review by Dennis D. McDonald
I discovered this graphic novel in the children's section of our local public library and was immediately intrigued.
The story centers on a young mermaid, the main attraction at a quaint, multi-story seaside aquarium. The owner of the aquarium, who masquerades as "King Neptune" during daily shows, entices visitors with glimpses of "Fish Girl," the star. She communicates with her fellow sea creatures, her closest companion being a giant octopus she has known since childhood.
As the narrative unfolds, the mermaid's desire for freedom grows, fueled by the glimpses of the outside world she sees from her luxuriously appointed tank. A local schoolgirl eventually befriends her.
The illustrations in this oversized graphic novel are detailed, realistic, colorful, and breathtaking. The narrative is sensitive, emotional, engaging, and dramatic, with whimsical and occasionally troubling elements.
Fish Girl’s “Bedroom”
One disturbing aspect, introduced early on, is the depiction of "King Neptune" who acts as the mermaid's father, protector, and jailer. He cares for her but also exploits her as the main draw of his large seaside aquarium. This theme of male domination gave me pause, but I chose to borrow the book and read it over four nights to my six-year-old granddaughter. Despite her young age, she has developed a sophisticated taste in media; she enjoys the Harry Potter series with her parents and has loved watching movies like "Suzume" and "Bubble" with me.
She adored "Fish Girl," particularly the ending—which I won't spoil. She was delighted by the resolution for all the right reasons.
Review copyright (c) 2024 by Dennis D. McDonald
